Paper review

Your name: _____________________________________________

Paper reviewed : _____________________________________________

In your own words:

  1. What problem is the paper trying to solve?


  2. What ideas do the authors present to help solve the problem?


  3. What previous work does this idea build on?


  4. What are the details of the main algorithm?


  5. How did the authors implement the algorithm?


  6. How were the results measured and compared?


  7. What were the main limitations of the paper?


  8. Could you implement the idea?

  9. Rate the overall quality of the paper:

    Poor 1 ..... 2 ..... 3 ..... 4 ..... 5 Good

  10. Rate the clarity of the paper:

    Poor 1 ..... 2 ..... 3 ..... 4 ..... 5 Good